Showing posts with label American Revolutionary War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Revolutionary War. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Louisa Catherine Adams-The Fifth First Lady of the United States (Part III)

by Lauren Gilbert

Louisa Catherine Johnson Adams by Gilbert Stuart 1821-1826


Part I can be found HERE
Part II can be found HERE

As we’ve seen, Louisa Johnson married John Quincy Adams on July 26, 1797, and discovered her father, who went back to America with the rest of her family shortly afterwards, was in debt to the wide and did not pay her dowry of 5000 pounds. According to some sources, John Quincy turned the household accounts, normally handled by a wife, over to his valet and left her feeling  that he included her in his disillusionment with her father and family resulting from his being approached by Joshua Johnson’s creditors. Although they shared some interests, including reading, and were genuinely in love, theirs was a difficult union: two insecure and extremely sensitive people, one of whom considered himself the master, to teach and lead the other (John Quincy) while the other yearned to be a partner with a voice who was not afraid to stand up for herself (Louisa). On top of this, Louisa became pregnant almost immediately. By all accounts, this was a difficult pregnancy; John Quincy’s own diaries make frequent references to Mrs. Adams’ sickness. It is also pertinent to remember that Napoleon was making himself felt on the continent. They finally left for John Quincy’s posting in Berlin on October 18, 1797, requiring a difficult sea crossing and an equally difficult land journey to Berlin which took six days. Shortly after settling into a hotel, Louisa suffered the first of multiple miscarriages almost immediately after their arrival. It was a long-drawn-out and excruciatingly painful ordeal for which the doctors could do little. To his credit, John Quincy was a support and took great care of Louisa during this time, and the situation united them much more closely. They settled into lodgings, and Louisa began her recovery; John Quincy presented his credentials, was presented and immediately began participating in the Prussian court society. 

Louisa, left to herself in the lodgings, became very lonely as she received no visitors and no invitations, while John Quincy made no effort to have her presented at court. Discovering that Queen Louise was starting to think that John Quincy and Louisa were not married, John Quincy escorted Louisa to the theatre one evening when the King and Queen of Prussia were expected to attend, and Louisa drew considerable attention. Subsequently, she was presented to Queen Louise, with whom she became quite friendly. Close in age to Louisa, Queen Louise was renowned for her beauty and charm, and she was also extremely kind. Louisa’s background, between her family’s social activities and her involvement with Anglo-American circles with Mr. and Mrs. Pinckney in London, fitted her to shine in diplomatic society abroad. Her fluent French was also an advantage. Unbeknownst to John Quincy, she became a significant asset to him, especially since diplomacy was (as it still is) conducted in social settings almost as much as in conference rooms. While he was waiting for her to make a mistake and cause him embarrassment, Louisa was busy becoming a success, meeting people and smoothing his way. This would become a recurring theme throughout their marriage. In the meanwhile, John Quincy worried about her acquiring monarchical tendencies, too fond of pomp and circumstances for American tastes (especially his mother’s). Ironically, because John Quincy was the son of the American president as well as an ambassador, they were given a higher place in court protocol than may have been expected. Of course, this meant they had to entertain as well as attend court functions (which meant appropriate apparel for both) on an extremely limited budget and while Louisa continued to experience poor health. She apparently had difficult menstrual cycles and suffered multiple miscarriages which deeply pained her and John Quincy both. It was during this time that she developed the on-going health problems for which she was subsequently know, which included debilitating headaches and fainting spells.  

In February of 1801, they received news of two painful events: John Adams lost the presidency to Thomas Jefferson, and John Quincy’s brother Charles died. The bright spot came on April 12 of 1801, when Louisa delivered a living son whom they named George Washington Adams, after yet another difficult and painful labour. Although she subsequently suffered a high fever and was very ill, she was recovering when John Quincy and his family were ordered to return to the United States. They left Berlin on June 17, 1801. Louisa was on her way to America, a place she had never visited even though she was a citizen. Apparently, during the trip, John Quincy also told her all about Mary Frazier and his failed courtship, which could not have helped her feel more confident. Upon arrival, John Quincy went to Massachusetts to his family home, and she took baby George and went to see her family in Georgetown, near Washington. The visit was not very happy by all accounts: Mr. Johnson’s financial problems were known, he was in poor health, and John Quincy’s absence was noted. In October, John Quincy came to get her and George to bring them home to John and Abigail Adams’ house.

Louisa’s entrance into the Adams’ family was not easy. John and Abigail made no pretence of sincere friendliness; with her foreign upbringing, she felt equally out of place with them. Abigail in particular disapproved of Louisa as a fine lady, and Louisa had no training to be the kind of housewife that Abigail would find suitable. Abigail was also concerned about Louisa’s poor health. Louisa herself was very aware of the differences between her upbringing as an American in England, and felt the differences keenly. Eventually, her intelligence, love of reading and genuine desire for approval won over John Adams and they did develop a close friendship. Her relationship with Abigail was much more difficult, as John Quincy developed a bad habit of discussing his household issues with his mother, then informing his wife of the decisions that he and his mother made. Louisa, of course, would make known her objections, and then ultimately go along. It cannot be a coincidence that her health issues, particularly the headaches and fainting spells continued. They moved into their own home in Boston, but issues did not improve as Louisa did not know how to manage the household, especially as she was expected to participate in the work of the household. Money was, as always , short, and John Quincy kept track of every cent and never hesitated to  show his aggravation. John Quincy was extremely busy with his law practice and in May of 1801 became a representative to the state senate. Louisa was left on her own increasingly. In February of 1803, he was appointed to the United States Senate by the legislature. Louisa, pregnant again, discovered she would be going to Washington just when she was starting to feel settled. Their second child was born July 4, 1803 and named John. The family arrived in Washington on October 20, 1803. This was the beginning of Louisa’s life as a political wife.

Their children were a special bone of contention. In the fall of 1805, John Quincy decided to leave their two sons in Massachusetts, without consulting Louisa and with Abigail’s complicity, while he and Louisa went to Washington.  Louisa was upset but went along. In addition to missing her children, she was experiencing a difficult pregnancy. Because of her pregnancy, John Quincy left her in Washington when he returned to Massachusetts for the summer (now without him AND her children). Sadly, her pregnancy resulted in a still birth.  Louisa finally made it home to Massachusetts in August 1806. The next term of Congress, she and the children stayed in Boston in miserable lodgings, again without consultation with Louisa. Clearly, John Quincy had no intention of allowing Louisa a voice, even though he consulted regularly with his mother. Equally clearly, Louisa made her anger at being so treated known, but went along anyway. During the summer of 1807, Louisa was pregnant again and she gave birth to a third son after yet another excruciating labour (the baby, named Charles Francis, was breech). When John Quincy took his family back to Washington for the 1807-1808 term, she was allowed to take the new baby; the two older children again stayed behind, this time boarding with John Quincy’s aunts (Abigail’s sisters) individually (George with Elizabeth Peabody and John with Mary Cranch). Louisa submitted, but not happily, and she did not agree that child rearing by proxy was good for her children. Given the number of miscarriages she had and the difficult labours she experienced, her attachment to her living children must have been particularly intense.  

Increasing political activity stemming from tension with Great Britain took John Quincy away even more and resulted him changing parties from the Federalists to the Republicans in support of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison. This resulted in his resigning his Senate seat and the family returning again to Boston in 1808, only to face social ostracism. Even John and Abigail Adams were upset about his change. He went to Washington to conduct three cases before the Supreme Court, again leaving Louisa and his children behind. She had become  pregnant again but lost the baby early in 1809 while John Quincy was away,  when she slipped and fell on ice. They had argued before he left, and conducted a bitter exchange of letters, even after the miscarriage. In July of 1809, the Madison administration offered John Quincy the position of minister plenipotentiary to Russia, which he accepted. Despite their friction, John Quincy wanted Louisa with him. He made arrangement, again with Abigail, to leave the two older boys with an aunt and uncle, while Louisa and little Charles accompanied him. There is no indication Louisa had any participation in deciding who would go with them and who would stay behind. This time, Louisa’s sister Kitty was among the party to go so at least she had a family member with her when they took ship on August 5, 1809, beginning an eighty-day voyage.  

Their arrival was difficult, as they had only the clothing they stood up in as, after they got off the ship in Kronstadt, it floated back out to sea with all of their belongings. They had to go on to St. Petersburg. The beginning of John Quincy’s mission was not going well: the drinking water had affected everyone (diarrhea), and they discovered that their luggage had been ransacked when it was finally returned. Again, as an ambassador, John Quincy and his wife were expected to be part of the social scene and, again, John Quincy was focused on their lack of money. Even though he was much more than he had been in Prussia (Louisa Thomas indicates only the president was paid more [1]).  Unfortunately, the Russian court was vastly wealthier, the social duties were heavier (almost nightly), and the entire party needed complete new wardrobes-they had to keep up with the Joneses with a vengeance, so to speak.

John Quincy’s assignment included fostering good relations with the Russians and there was no way for him or for Louisa to evade their social responsibilities. The expenses of daily living, combined with the costs of wardrobe suitable for court brought Louisa’s anxiety about her dowry to the forefront again. However, in spite of the financial hemorrhage resulting, Louisa enjoyed parties and dancing. She did not enjoy the high status she had held in Prussia (thanks largely to her friendship with Queen Louise) but did succeed in charming the Russian court and once again being an asset to John Quincy. The high-waisted flowing style we now associate with the Regency era in England was popular in Russia, and Louisa became very creative in stretching her and Kitty’s wardrobe funds as much as possible, not least in sewing their own gowns. Both John Quincy and Louisa bemoaned the exorbitant costs of living in Russia at this time, while carrying out their duties. Louisa suffered another miscarriage in February of 1810, but got back into her routine as quickly as possible. In the spring of 1811, John Quincy was offered a position on the Supreme Court. However, he declined, using the fact that Louisa was pregnant as an excuse. On August 11, after an uneventful pregnancy and labour, she delivered a little girl, who was named after her mother, Louisa Catherine. Louisa and John Quincy were both entranced with their daughter. John Quincy had sent for their sons in March of 1812, but war being declared with Great Britain, their trip was postponed indefinitely. The vast distance delayed news between the United States and Russia, and Louisa was much more experienced with separation from her family and children, so she was able to take comfort of Charles and Louisa Catherine.  Sadly, Louisa Catherine became ill and, after a long illness died September 15, 1812, the same day Napoleon rode through Moscow.
 
Both John Quincy and Louisa were devastated by her death. John Quincy was able to find some comfort in his work, but Louisa’s grief did not abate. John Quincy’s response was to buy her a book by Benjamin Rush, MEDICAL INQUIRIES and OBSERVATIONS, UPON DISEASES of the MIND. Not exactly a sensitive gift. She blamed herself for her child’s death and missed her two sons left behind more than ever; these feelings rekindled her anger with John Quincy. He was relieved when he asked to be part of a peace commission, which resulted in his departure April 28, 1814 and which was to keep him away for several months, leaving Louisa and Charles in St. Petersburg. Her health was never robust. Ironically, during her time in Russia, Louisa and her mother-in-law drew closer than they had ever been by letter. John Quincy’s departure left Louisa in complete charge of the household, while expecting her to maintain her social responsibilities. After years of not being allowed to handle anything, it is not unreasonable to assume that Louisa doubted her own abilities. However, she rose to the occasion and even enjoyed being in charge. Their letters indicate that they seem to have reconciled their differences at least to some extent, and showed a mutual affection. However, the prospect of yet another Russian winter, this time with John Quincy away, put a further strain on her. The peace commission took longer than anyone anticipated, but peace with Great Britain was finally concluded in December 1814. At that point, John Quincy dropped a bombshell on her: he informed her that he would not be returning to Russia and ordered her to sell everything she did not want to keep for the best price possible, and bring their son to join him in Paris as soon as she was able.  This put Louisa in position for a journey that was a defining experience in her life, and an illustration of the strength and character of this fascinating woman.


Part IV will discuss Louisa’s journey from St. Petersburg to Paris, her further career in Washington as the wife of Secretary of State and as First Lady, and our conclusion.

Notes:
[1] Thomas, Louisa.  LOUISA  The Extraordinary Life of Mrs. Adams. P. 172.

Sources include:
See sources listed in Parts I and II and

Caroli, Betty Boyd.  THE FIRST LADIES from Martha Washington to Michelle Obama 4th edition.  New York: Madison Park Press (an imprint of Direct Brands, Inc.), 2009.

Heffron, Margery M. LOUISA CATHERINE The Other Mrs. Adams.  New Haven: Yale University Press, 2014.

Roberts, Cokie.  LADIES OF LIBERTY The Women Who Shaped Our Nation.  New York: HarperCollins, 2008.

Thomas, Louisa.  LOUISA The Extraordinary Life of Mrs. Adams.  New York: Penguin Press, 2016.

Withey, Lynne.  DEAREST FRIEND A Life of Abigail Adams.  New York: Touchstone/Simon & Schuster, 2001 (originally published 1981 by the Free Press).

Image: Wikimedia Commons, HERE

About the author: Lauren Gilbert is the author of HEYERWOOD: A Novel, released in 2011.  A second novel A RATIONAL ATTACHMENT is in process.  She lives in Florida with her husband, with some roses (white ones are blooming) and gardenias, herbs and pineapples.  Please visit her website at www.lauren-gilbert.com for more information.



Monday, January 23, 2017

Louisa Catherine Adams, The Fifth First Lady of the United States-Part II

by Lauren Gilbert

Louisa Catherine Johnson, 1794

Part I can be found HERE.

Louisa Johnson’s family was known to the Adams family, a family on a level with nobility in the fledgling United States of America. John Quincy’s parents, John and Abigail, were in London and Paris between 1784 and 1788, when John was the first ambassador to Great Britain. Although not yet consul, Joshua and his wife would have been part of the Anglo-American society with whom John and Abigail would at least have been acquainted. Previously, John and John Quincy were known to have met up with the Johnson family while they were sojourning in Nantes in France. There is no indication that John Quincy and Louisa had any prior acquaintance themselves (she was much younger).  They met when John Quincy was ordered from Holland to London to help with an official act. Due to travel delays, John Quincy did not arrive in time; business was concluded without him. He was kicking his heels, waiting for orders to return to his duties as resident minister of Holland, when he found his way to dinner at the Johnsons’ house.  There he resumed his acquaintance with Mr. and Mrs. Johnson and enjoyed the society of their family and friends. He was considered a handsome young man, and a portrait of him can be seen HERE.  

Before we go further, it is important to understand a bit about both of these individuals. Louisa had strong ideas about marriage and a woman’s role. She viewed her parents’ relationship as idyllic, reminiscing about how her father had adored her mother and catered to her. At the same time, her father also espoused a very traditional role for women, in the home and subordinate to her husband.  (This was still a time, when a couple married, the two became one and the man was the one.) Louisa’s own reading and thinking led her to want more. She wanted a voice in her life and decisions affecting her, and she wanted the kind of marriage that she thought her parents had. Louisa was also rather insecure about many things. She considered her older sister Nancy to be the belle and beauty of the family. Quite slender, almost unfashionably so, with large dark eyes, she did not consider herself particularly attractive or talented, although accounts indicate otherwise. Most of all, she felt compelled to hide her intelligence and her desires, as she did not believe men would be attracted to those attributes. The traditional duty of a woman of her time and status was to marry as well as possible to please her parents. In many respects, she was spoiled; in others, she was stifled.

John Quincy, as the son of John and Abigail Adams, was raised to be an achiever. His parents planned his education and career and made the decisions at all levels. Both parents pushed him hard to excel in his studies. His career path was to study law and follow in his father’s footsteps. The trouble was he was not particularly interested in the law, nor did he particularly want to follow his father’s path into public service. His father’s work and the war caused frequent separations, and both parents wrote frequently about the importance of his studies, his duty to his family and his country, and setting forth the high expectations they held for him. He became insecure, feeling that he could never fully meet their expectations, and frustrated because he did not trust his own preferences and desires. He loved and respected his parents but also felt resentment for their constant pressure and control over his life. (He seems to have had especially mixed emotions for his mother; she was a very strong woman who made decisions and had a strong partnership with her husband. He loved and admired her, but also seemed to have resented her influence and strength.) As an adult, he was torn between what he felt he ought to do in terms of continuing his studies and pursuing his work versus the things he wanted to do. Leisure was a particularly difficult issue for him. He enjoyed parties and society and felt guilty for indulging in leisure activities. He felt he could never live up to his parents’ expectations for him and did not always trust his own abilities. He had been in love with and wanted to marry a girl named Mary Frazier and gave her up at the insistence of his parents, a sore point for the rest of his life.

So John Quincy joined the Johnson family for dinner and became a regular in their society. He did not appear to pay particular attention to any of the girls but, in time, he mentioned her by name in his diary expressing his appreciation of her singing. He was present socially on a frequent basis, including his attendance at Louisa’s older sister Nancy’s birthday ball in November 1795. Many people (including Louisa, apparently) believed he was courting Nancy (a logical assumption given she was the elder and considered the beauty). Catherine Johnson was pleased by the prospect, although there were indications that Joshua was not, given his desire for his daughters to marry Americans from the south.   A ball for Louisa’s upcoming 21st birthday was held January 27, 1796, and John Quincy made his interest in Louisa known. This caused a serious upset in the family, given that Nancy considered him to be courting her as did many other people, and no one had any inkling it was Louisa to whom he was attracted.  Nancy was angry and humiliated, and she took it out on Louisa. Then, having made his interest known, John Quincy did not appear to be disposed to do anything more about it. While Catherine was in favour of the marriage, her father seemed resigned (financial problems made husbands for his daughters very attractive). However, having declared his intentions, John Quincy did not propose marriage.  He was due to return to his duties in Holland and, despite spending more time with the Johnsons than ever, seemed almost to hope to get away.  Finally in April, Catherine Johnson demanded a meeting with him and insisted on knowing his intentions.  John Quincy, despite his apparent reluctance, and Louisa became engaged, and Joshua promised her dowry of 5000 pounds.  However, John Quincy insisted on returning to Holland (he was ordered to return in May) without being married, and that he would not marry Louisa until his appointment was concluded and he was able to resume his law practice and was able to support her; in other words, they were engaged but had no definite plans to marry. At this time, long engagements were not the norm. This situation left Louisa in an uncertain state, insecure about his affection and facing the possibility of estrangement in time. John Quincy returned to Holland, unmarried, while Louisa resigned herself to wait.

John Quincy and Louisa began a correspondence. Both of them were short tempered, insecure and uncertain of the future. They meant to be agreeable to each other. He told her his plans and expectations; she tried to mould herself accordingly. They tried to be romantic, but were unable to find a real connection. Then, John Quincy was appointed minister to Portugal. To Louisa, this seemed an opportunity for them to marry; he could stop in England on the way to Lisbon, they could marry, he could take her with him. This was not an acceptable plan to John Quincy. The concern about supporting her was the same.  However, she also felt his letters implied that he did not truly feel she would be a suitable wife for him. In the meanwhile, Joshua was facing extreme financial difficulty and planned to take his family back to America that summer, and John and Abigail Adams were writing letters to John Quincy deploring the marriage. They counselled delay, to wait til his prospects were more settled. Abigail felt that Louisa was too European and would not fit in as an American, even though naturalized. That did not faze John Quincy, so the tactics changed; John and Abigail expressed concern that time in a European court would corrupt her, turning her into a monarchist, so they discouraged his taking Louisa with him to Lisbon. Louisa asked if they could at least see each other, even offering to come to Holland with her parents. Unfortunately, John Quincy responded by accusing her of planning to be left behind in Holland, basically trapping him. Frequent correspondents, letters flew back and forth, neither waiting for a response before firing off another. Harsh words were exchanged, and each gave the other the opportunity to break it off. However, making it clear that his first obligation would always be to his country, John Quincy came to England July 12, 1797.

John Quincy had made it clear that Louisa would never be his first priority, and it showed when he did not visit her until the day after his arrival. To his surprise, when he asked Louisa to set the wedding date, she selected a date two weeks away. She felt insecure and wanted to get it done. (Her father was also in a hurry, as his finances required that the family return to the United States as soon as possible; marrying Louisa off would mean one less person to transport and feed.) John Adams was, by now, President of the United States, and he threw a further monkey wrench into their  plans by changing his appointment from Portugal to Prussia, a more prestigious position. John Quincy deplored nepotism, but took the appointment anyway, not least because it was troublesome to him. (He seemed to feel a particular virtue in annoyance and struggle.) He had already had his possessions shipped to Lisbon. Louisa and John Quincy were finally married on July 26, and they celebrated for several weeks, concluding in a ball given by Louisa’s father on August 25. John Quincy and Louisa moved to the Adelphi Hotel to stay til their departure for Berlin in October. Her family joined them for dinner on September 8, which turned out to be a farewell, as Joshua was taking the family to the US immediately (earlier than planned), the result of a financial disaster about which Louisa knew little or nothing. They left the hotel and went straight to the ship. Then Louisa discovered that, in addition to leaving her without warning, he had not paid her dowry to John Quincy, a violation of their marriage agreement. This was a serious blow, as she felt that John Quincy and other people would assume she knew that her father would  not pay. John Quincy had always been concerned about money, and her father’s default and the subsequent scandal put her in a embarrassing and difficult position, especially when creditors appeared at their hotel. The timing was especially bad, as John Quincy had left his savings with his brother Charles to invest, and Charles had lost it. John Quincy received a letter from a colleague of Mr. Johnson's, implying that John Quincy had knowledge of Joshua’s failure, and gave the letter with his reply to Louisa to read.  The whole situation left her shattered and humiliated.


Part III will continue with their married life. Their marriage would last fifty-four years.

Sources include:

(In addition to those cited in Part I)
Roberts, Cokie.  LADIES OF LIBERTY.  New York: William Morrow (an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers), 2008.

Withey, Lynne.  DEAREST FRIEND A Life of Abigail Adams.   New York: Touchstone (trademark of Simon and Schuster), 1981.

Caroli, Betty Boyd.  THE FIRST LADIES From Martha Washington to Michelle Obama, 4th edition.  New York: Madison Park Presss, 2009.

Image of Louisa: Wikimedia Commons HERE.

Source for image of John Quincy Adams: NewEnglandHistoricalSociety.com, "John Quincy Complains About Kissing."  No author or post date provided.  HERE

About the author: Lauren Gilbert is the author of HEYERWOOD: A Novel, released in 2011.  A second novel A RATIONAL ATTACHMENT is in process.  She lives in Florida with her husband, with some roses and gardenia, herbs and pineapples.  Please visit her website at HERE.


Sunday, January 15, 2017

Louisa Catherine Adams-The Fifth First Lady of the United States (Part I)


by Lauren Gilbert


Louisa Catherine Johnson 1794

Best known for being the first and (until inauguration day January 20, 2017) the only foreign-born first lady, Louisa Adams did not see the United States until she had been married four years.  She was married to John Quincy Adams, son of John and Abigail Adams, in spite of their and her father’s disapproval, and her own doubts.  Known for ill health and physical delicacy, she was also capable of decisive action when the situation required.  In their long marriage (from July 26, 1797 to John Quincy’s death February 23, 1848), they had several periods of separation and serious points of disagreement; however, she did everything she could to further his career and their letters show an on-going attachment.  Her life was a long and fascinating life, filled with adventures, trials and successes.   What intrigues me most about her is her rather unique point of view and her inner dialogues.

Louisa Catherine Johnson was born February 12, 1775 to Joshua Johnson and Catherine Newth or Nuth.  She was the second child, and second daughter, born in a family of nine children (eight girls and one boy).  Born in Maryland, Joshua Johnson was an American merchant, whose business was originally located in Maryland, arrived in England in 1771 at the behest of his employer Charles Wallace to act as the representative of Wallace, Davidson and Johnson, an importing firm they started in Annapolis MD, trading tobacco and mercantile goods.  Catherine Nuth was an English woman and possibly the daughter of a shoemaker who was known for her beauty and wit.   In November of 1773, their first child Ann (known as Nancy) was born.  Joshua’s business practices were highly speculative.  In 1778, at the height of the hostilities between America and Great Britain, Joshua took his family to Nantes, France. Louise was placed with Nancy in a convent school where she learned fluent French and was exposed to the Roman Catholic faith.  The family returned to London after peace was established, about 1783. 

After their return to England, Louisa had to relearn the English language.  Louisa was enrolled in boarding school with two sisters, where she did not fit in well, coming out of a French convent school.    Her studies included mathematics, stitching and embroidery, drawing and (interestingly) philosophy.  While at school, Louisa experienced a period of illness (including fainting) after which she was removed from school and was placed with some family friends, John and Elizabeth Hewlett. Both were highly intelligent and rather radical.  John helped wean Louisa from the Catholic ideas she had acquired in France to a more normal Anglican tradition, and Elizabeth was a strong minded woman (not the passive, dependent type admired by Louisa’s father and portrayed in current literature).   When Louisa returned to school, she came under the influence of a teacher, Miss Young, who encouraged her to read widely and think for herself and to express her thoughts.  An intelligent girl, she developed an interest in science, read controversial authors of the day, and questioned herself and her beliefs as well as her place and the place of women in general in her world.  She spent her pocket money on books.   After a few years, she and her sisters were removed from school in 1788 due to her father’s facing bankruptcy, about which the girls were kept in ignorance.  The girls then had a governess.  After some dispute (including concerns about Joshua’s lavish lifestyle), Joshua’s business partnership was extended, but financial problems resulted in the partnership being dissolved in 1789.  Joshua established himself on his own.  However, things weren’t the same, at least in part due to a decline in the Maryland tobacco trade and increased manufacturing of goods in America. 

An interesting side note: a marriage record exists showing that Joshua Johnson married Catherine Newth on August 22, 1785 in Westminster.   She had been known as Catherine Johnson, wife of Joshua Johnson, for years, and all of their children’s births were recorded as legitimate accordingly; there is no indication that she was not Joshua’s wife.  Certainly, there is no indication that neighbours, friends or their children were aware of any irregularity.  However, there is also no known record of an earlier marriage.  At least five of their children were born before the recorded marriage in 1785.  If that was in fact their only marriage, discovery could have meant scandal if not ruin for Joshua Johnson and his family.  Joshua was appointed consul by then-President Thomas Jefferson to act for America in England in 1790 (an appointment which would have been very unlikely if there had been questions about his marriage).  This appointment required him to report information about British shipping and preparations for war and locations of British fishing and whaling fleets.  He was also to help American seaman who had been impressed by the British when possible and to provide local intelligence of a political nature.  In return, Mr. Johnson made it clear that being in that position was expensive and had no hesitation in pursuing remuneration from Mr. Jefferson and Congress.

Mr. Johnson considered himself an American wholeheartedly, and there is an act recorded in the annals of the Maryland senate stating that he and his children were American citizens.  He intended, at some future point, to take his family to America and intended his daughters to marry Americans (preferably from the south).  Joshua had a very traditional view of the role of women.  However, his daughters were raised as proper English girls of well-to-do families were raised: they were educated, taught to sing, play an instrument and dance, how to speak French and how to supervise servants.  Although learning to manage servants included learning to cook and to make and mend clothes, the young ladies’  “work” was primarily decorative embroidery.  They were prepared for courtship and marriage, to be fine ladies who were cared for, not to be help meets.  She and her siblings experienced none of the alarms, privations and practical experience of girls raised in America during the Revolutionary period.  This difference in upbringing and outlook would affect Louisa’s entire life.  Louisa and her two  sisters Nancy and Caroline basically made their social debuts more or less at the same time, with Louisa being fifteen years old and Caroline a year younger.  Louisa was a pretty girl, more slender than was strictly fashionable, with large dark eyes.  Louisa was known to be shy and somewhat retiring but was very observant of what was going on around her.  In spite of Mr. Johnson’s financial fluctuations, the family entertained but, because no formal diplomatic relationship had been established between the United States and Great Britain, Johnson’s access to Parliament or court was restricted to secretaries and lower level officials, limiting his activities as consul as well as his family’s social access. 

It wasn’t until August of 1792, when Thomas Pinckney, appointed minister plenipotentiary, finally arrived in London with his wife Elizabeth that the social opportunities arose for the Johnson family.  Louisa became a favourite of Mrs. Pinckney and was allowed to visit and stay with her.  Mr. and Mrs. Pinckney were welcomed into Anglo-American society and, as a result, the Johnson family also had some access to that society, mingling with members of Parliament, artists and other notables.  Pretty, well dressed and well mannered, Louisa and her sisters were allowed to attend the social functions when invited, gaining a social polish and understanding of status.  Sadly,   Elizabeth Pinckney died two years after arriving in London, to Louisa’s sorrow.  Louisa, Nancy and Caroline all had beaus and flirtations. However, Mr. Johnson was quite selective on his daughters’ behalves, discouraging multiple suitors of each.  Although not wealthy, the young ladies were raised to expect a dowry of 5000 pounds each, so had no reason to expect that there would be difficulty receiving suitable offers.  (There is nothing to indicate that Mrs. Johnson or any of her daughters were aware of the vagaries of Mr. Johnson’s finances.)  Louisa did not seem to have been in a hurry to marry, enjoying the social activities and engaging a variety of individuals with her singing and conversation. Interestingly, she felt her intelligence and wide reading was not an asset for a young woman seeking a marriage partner, so she concealed that aspect of herself. It was as a polished young lady that Louisa met John Quincy Adams, resident minister to Holland and son of John and Abigail Adams.


In Part II, we will discuss Louisa’s marriage to John Quincy, her feelings and her experiences.

Sources include:
Britannica.com  “Louisa Adams American First Lady” by Betty Boyd Caroli, May 28, 2004. Here.

 Find-a-grave on line.  “Louisa Catherine Johnson Adams,” biography by William Bjornstad (no post date).  Here.

Firstladies.org  “First Lady Biography: Louisa Adams.” (No author or post date shown) Here.

Nps.gov  “Louisa Catherine Adams  (1775-1852).”  (no author or post date shown)  Here.

Smithsonian.com “Meet the First and Only Foreign-born First Lady: Louisa Catherine Adams” by Jackie Mansky, May 25, 2016. Here.

White House Historical Association on-line. “Louisa Adams.” (no author or post date shown.)  Here. 

Zocalopublicsquare.org  “From a London Alley to the White House” by Louisa Thomas, October 31, 2014.  Here. 

Heffron, Margery M. LOUISA CATHERINE The Other Mrs. Adams.  New Haven: Yale University Press, 2014.

Thomas, Louisa.  LOUISA The Extraordinary Life of Mrs. Adams.  New York: Penguin Press, 2016. 

Image Credit
By Edward Savage [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Louisa_Catherine_Adams.jpg

~~~~~~~~~~~~
About the author: Lauren Gilbert is the author of Heyerwood: A Novel, released in 2011.  A second novel, A Rational Attachment, is in process.  She lives in Florida with her husband, with some roses and gardenia, herbs and pineapples.  Please visit her website here  for more information.




Friday, November 18, 2016

Margaret Shippen Arnold, Collaborator or Dupe? Part III

By Lauren Gilbert

So far in this series we have been introduced to Peggy (Margaret) Shippen, and the career of her husband, Benedict Arnold. * Part II concluded with the end of the American Revolution ** but our story did not end there:

Peggy Shippen and her daughter, c 1783-1789

As time passed, things grew harder for the Arnold family as his income declined: he had made military expenditures from personal funds that had yet to be repaid and had had failed efforts in trade. He attempted to borrow money without success. The family moved from the home he had been assigned as major general of Philadelphia, which they still occupied when in town and not at Mount Pleasant, to a smaller one belonging to his father-in-law in an attempt to retrench. Another blow fell on Arnold on April 6 of 1780, when Washington issued the required reprimand. Washington tried to soften it as much as he could, and wrote him a private letter to encourage him to put the matter behind him and work to rebuild his reputation. It seems this was the last straw; Arnold turned fully to British General Clinton and Major André, determined to seek a significant command to generate the needed boost to the British efforts. West Point fit the requirements due to its strategic position north of New York on the Hudson River (a major waterway), conquest of which would severely damage the Continental army’s activities. While jockeying for the appointment to command of West Point, Arnold continued his bargaining with Clinton and André for financial guarantees. On the home front in Philadelphia, Peggy was using her social skills to lobby support for Arnold’s desired appointment as well.
 
Benedict Arnold

In July of 1780, Washington offered Arnold command of the left wing of the army, which was considered a significant honour. Arnold’s lack of enthusiasm for the post or gratitude for the appointment was noted not only by Washington but others, who wondered why Arnold wasn’t pleased. Fortunately, from Arnold’s perspective, Washington ordered him to West Point to take command upon hearing that the British fleet was returning to New York. Arnold arrived at West Point August 5, 1780, and began efforts to resupply the fort with a view to British advantage, not American, although Washington remained ignorant of his intent. Finally accepting that Arnold really meant his offer to put West Point into British hands, General Sir Henry Clinton offered Arnold 20,000 pounds if the British captured three thousand soldiers with the fort. The assignment of an artillery unit by Washington to the fort put sufficient men in place to make that a possibility. A meeting was scheduled between Arnold and André on the opposite shore of the river on September 11 but didn’t happen due to communications failures. Peggy and their baby son arrived at West Point on September 14, 1780 after an arduous trip of several days. One overnight stay for Peggy was at the Hermitage, the home of Anne Watkins, who had her daughter Theodosia Prevost with her, both known Loyalists. Theodosia was married to a British officer stationed in South Carolina at the time. This could have appeared to be a serious offense, except that Washington had stayed at the Hermitage earlier, knowing the family to hold divided loyalties.

Also on September 14, Washington told Arnold of his plans to meet French leaders in Connecticut and informed Arnold of arrangements to be made. Arnold immediately sent this information to the British, while assuring Washington the arrangement would be made. Arnold took his family to a country house that had been seized by the Americans, which was not convenient for the West Point post but was excellent from the standpoint of privacy and intrigue. Peggy’s presence was a perfect cover for Arnold’s secret treason. While entertaining at a dinner on September 17, Arnold received a missive advising him that Major André's arrival was expected, indicating the plot was proceeding. This must have been a nerve-wracking period, as the next day Washington indicated he was planning to come to West Point on September 23 and would stay with the Arnolds, a real prize for the British. Finally, on September 21, André arrived by ship, was rowed to shore and the meeting between Arnold and André came off. Things rapidly became complicated as André was in uniform and refused to cross the British line, to avoid the appearance of a spy. Arnold provided the information, and again tried to negotiate the money amount. Sunrise surprised them, and the major’s transport refused to row him back to his ship. At that point, André had no choice but to cross the lines. Subsequently, his ship was attacked, damaged and driven off, leaving André stranded. Arnold gave him two passes to help him cross through American territory to British held New York, and insisted that he take maps and documents back to Clinton. Arnold returned home, while André was left in disguise with guides to get him safely back. On September 23, Arnold was told that André had been safely seen to the British lines. On that day, Washington changed the plans to arrive with the Marquis de Lafayette, Henry Knox, Alexander Hamilton and other American notables on September 25.

When September 25 arrived, a completely fraught day ensued. Washington’s party was delayed, and Arnold received a letter at breakfast advising him that a certain John Anderson had been captured with papers about West Point in his boots. Arnold took Peggy upstairs and advised her of the situation. When Washington’s imminent arrival was announced, Arnold left the house, leaving a message that he would return. Peggy was left in her room, where she was when Washington arrived and ate breakfast. After Washington left to go to West Point, Peggy threw a hysterical fit, convincing their staff and a doctor that she was mad. Washington returned to the house that afternoon, at which point he was given a packet of letters containing the news of Arnold’s treason, a severe blow to Washington who had no inkling of Arnold’s disloyalty. Meanwhile, Peggy continued her histrionics. Arnold sent Washington a letter, attributing his defection to the ingratitude of his country, and asking him to protect Peggy, accepting full blame for his actions. He included a letter for Peggy, telling her to go to her parents or to come to him as she chose. Her despair and prolonged hysterical condition convinced Washington and the others that she was completely innocent of complicity in Arnold’s treason. Arnold, in the meantime, evaded capture and succeeded in making it to British lines.

Major André was brought as prisoner to the Arnold residence, and expected to be treated as a prisoner of war. Unfortunately, being caught in disguise, with incriminating documents, on foot in American territory made this unlikely, if not impossible. Washington immediately strengthened security at West Point, and word was sent to other posts. On September 26, André wrote a letter to Washington, divulging the facts of his case, asking to be treated with honour. Washington was not moved to leniency for the prisoner, nor did he meet with him. Although he subsequently tried to negotiate with General Clinton for an exchange of André for Arnold, Clinton’s refusal resulted in André’s death by hanging on October 1 after being found guilty of violating the rules of war. To the relief of all, the investigation indicated no wide-spread disaffection or plot. Also on September 26 as well, after considering her options, Peggy took her son and returned to Philadelphia to her parents. This journey was more difficult as she was recognized and was frequently scorned and refused service. On September 29, she stopped again at the Hermitage and visited with Theodosia Prevost. Allegedly, during this stay, she told Theodosia that she had maintained a correspondence with Major André and convinced Arnold to betray his country by turning West Point over to the British. (As a widow, Theodosia married Aaron Burr in 1782; Burr was the source of this story. It was refuted by a Shippen descendant, who said Burr told it to revenge himself on Peggy for rejecting his attempt to seduce her in a carriage; Peggy had had an escort and arrived at her parents’ home in early October, so it appeared the carriage ride never happened. However, some find Burr’s story more believable, in part because he waited until after everyone involved was dead to publish it. )

Once Arnold’s treason was announced, the Supreme Executive Council (including Arnold’s old enemy Joseph Reed) ordered a search for Arnold’s papers. The papers were found and included the letter written to Peggy by André in August of 1779 regarding their old friendship and millinery supplies, and a note she wrote to Arnold making fun of other women who had attended a concert. Despite her family’s support and defense, Peggy was now considered to be a conspirator in her husband’s treason, before she arrived back home. She took refuge in another fit of hysterics. Despite the limbo of her existence, Peggy maintained her loyalty to Arnold. In spite of her family’s efforts, the Supreme Executive Council ultimately decided on October 27, of 1780 that Peggy was to be exiled from the state of Pennsylvania and barred from returning during the course of the war. On November 29, Judge Shippen took Peggy and her son to the British lines at Paulus Hook and put them on a ship to New York City to join Arnold. She was 20 years old.

This is the point at which we must consider the question: was Peggy a collaborator in Benedict Arnold’s treason, or was she his dupe? It must be said that the destruction of all of her correspondence prior to the end of the war (except for the letter from Major André and the note from her to Arnold found in his papers) is suspicious; her subsequent correspondence is intact, and wholesale destruction of her earlier letters argues a significant secret. However, I think it unlikely that she was complicit from the beginning. She was very young during their courtship and marriage to Benedict Arnold, and he was already angry and bitter about his finances and his career. There is no indication of messages via other people or letters from Peggy to André prior to the letter she wrote in October of 1799, and there is no indication that she provided information or solicited any activity. While she did help lobby for the West Point appointment desired by Arnold with her social contacts, that is a reasonable action by a wife. An indulged, spoiled young woman who was known to throw tantrums to get her way would not necessarily be the best person in whom to confide a secret as serious as a treason plot. While there are documents showing she was paid 350 pounds by the British in 1792 for handling some secret dispatches, I was unable to discover what they were or when she supposedly handled them or what happened to them, so it’s hard for me to consider this payment as solid evidence that she was a full conspirator.

By the same token, I don’t think it reasonable to assume that she knew nothing until Arnold received word of André’s capture and left, leaving her to hide behind sustained hysteria to protect herself and her child from suspicion. Based on the data I’ve seen, it seems reasonable that the turning point was in the summer of 1779 when the Continental Congress referred Arnold back to the Supreme Executive Council for protection for his family, knowing the situation concerning the council and Arnold would make such protection highly unlikely. It seems a likely point where Arnold would confide the full range of his dissatisfaction and disillusionment, and where the couple, as a couple, would consider the options open for their family. Since Arnold had already been in correspondence with the British by this time, some degree of disclosure would not be such an unrealistic step. Given her family’s neutral stance politically, I think it very possible that Peggy may not have had strong political loyalties to either the Loyalist or the American cause; certainly I read of no instances of patriotic fervour (either way) on her part. Having observed her father and other families do what was needed to maintain their own security as their city changed governing armies, it seems very possible that Arnold’s switching sides did not particularly shock her. I believe she was complicit to the extent she knew he was plotting, but it seems highly unlikely that she was an active collaborator in the plot. As far as her correspondence is concerned, many families destroyed letters that contained embarrassing or otherwise compromising information-who knows how many wives and daughters of patriot families wearing linsey-woolsey that Peggy may have insulted, or remarks she may have made about Arnold’s continuing ire over his finances and status in the army that might have caused people to question her involvement? There could just as easily have been remarks about her own or other Loyalist or neutral families’ activities that could have raised questions about their loyalty and affected their post war future. Speculation is futile; it is, however, clear that there are many possible reasons for the destruction of her earlier letters besides her conspiring to commit treason.

What happened to the Arnolds afterwards? Benedict Arnold did serve with the British in 1781, but did not receive a command (his quarrelsome tendencies did not help him). He did receive money, but at 6000 pounds it was much less than he had wanted and expected (neither West Point nor the 3000 troops fell into British hands as a result of his plot, after all). Although Peggy’s wit and charm won her a welcome, the conviction that Arnold was in it for the money when he changed sides and his tendency to quarrel prevented him from being respected. He and Peggy had another son while living in New York. They sailed for London December 15, 1781 and arrived January 22, 1782. The Arnolds were welcomed initially, living in London where Arnold built a business in trade. Peggy and their children received pensions from the British government. She remained a very loyal wife to him. Unfortunately, despite numerous endeavours, including an opportunity in New Brunswick Canada (Arnold went to Canada in 1784; Peggy joined him in 1787), Arnold’s difficulties in dealing with other people and apparent lack of business acumen resulted in deeper and deeper debt. In 1789, Peggy visited her family in Philadelphia but was coldly received socially. She returned to Canada in the spring of 1790. They went back to London in 1792, and their last child was born there in 1794. They moved to progressively smaller homes. In 1801, Benedict Arnold’s health deteriorated and he died June 14, 1801. Peggy paid off her husband’s debts and managed to leave an inheritance for their children. She died of cancer on August 24, 1804, a British citizen. Both of them were buried in St. Mary’s Churchyard in Battersea, London.

* Read Part I 
** Read Part II 

============
Sources include:

Flexner, James Thomas. WASHINGTON The Indispensable Man. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1974.
Stuart, Nancy Rubin. DEFIANT BRIDES The Untold Story of Two Revolutionary-Era Women and the Radical Men They Married. Boston: Beacon Presss, 2013.
Find A Grave.com. “Margaret ‘Peggy’ Shippen Arnold.” Posted by Peggy, Nov. 28, 2009. HERE ;
"Benedict Arnold." (No name or post date.) HERE
Scandalous Women blog. “Treacherous Beauty: The Life of Peggy Shippen Arnold.” Posted Nov. 1, 2012 by Elizabeth Kerry Mahon. HERE
Smithsonian.com. “Why Benedict Arnold Turned Traitor Against the American Revolution” by Nathan Philbrick. Smithsonian Magazine, May 2016. HERE
AmericanRevolution.org. “Margaret Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Penn University Archives and Records Center on line. “Edward Shippen (1729-1806).” HERE (no name or post date)
History.com. “Benedict Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Wikipedia. “The Philadelphia Campaign.” HERE

Images from Wikimedia Commons.

~~~~~~~~~~

Lauren Gilbert lives in Florida with her husband. Her first book, HEYERWOOD A NOVEL, was published in 2011. Her second, A RATIONAL ATTACHMENT, is in process for release in 2017. Visit her website HERE





 

Saturday, November 12, 2016

Margaret Shippen Arnold, Collaborator or Dupe? - Part II

by Lauren Gilbert

Last week I introduced Peggy (Margaret Shippen) and the career of Benedict Arnold in a post, Margaret Shippen Arnold, Collaborator or Dupe (click here for the article).  Now we return to 18th century Philadelphia to pick up the story.

By the time of his appointment as Major General of Philadelphia, Benedict Arnold was chronically short of funds and had been writing to General Washington repeatedly about reimbursement for some time. He was also not happy about his rank, having been passed over for promotion while other (and younger) officers had received their promotions. He was finally promoted to brigadier general after the Battle of Ridgefield in 1777 without the fanfare he would have liked, and ultimately had his seniority restored after Saratoga later that year. He was not overly enthused about the position of Major General.

Benedict Arnold
Detail from mezzotint March 26, 1776

When the Americans took over the city of Philadelphia, the young ladies of the circle that enjoyed the attentions and entertainments of the British military were very disheartened, as it was known that the entertainments and social life they had enjoyed would not be continued. One of the first acts General Washington took was to declare a curfew for the night the British left. Once the army took possession of the city, Arnold sent the Massachusetts militia after the British to impede their progress to New York, and had workers clean the streets which were strewn with debris and (in places) garbage and waste left by the British. He also signed a Congressional resolve to close the shops. (This was in line with a policy of the Supreme Executive Council and was theoretically designed to make sure that the military could purchase needed goods fairly and to prevent abuse and profiteering.) Arnold also took residence in the Masters-Penn House, a stately and well-appointed mansion that was staffed by servants and included a coach. Shortly after the shops were closed, the clothier general of the army purchase goods at cost and sold them at top dollar. There was also a incident involving flour originally appropriated for the Army being sold in Havana at an extreme profit. These incidents caught the attention of Joseph Reed (who is said to have had designs on these goods himself), and were ultimately linked to Benedict Arnold.

Peggy Shippen with her daughter
At the same time, Arnold was courting friendships with wealthy and influential citizens, which tarnished his image as a neutral peace keeper and angered the revolutionary party. Although there were cries to try known Loyalists (or those who tried to stay neutral), cooler heads prevailed. However, known British sympathizers were ostracized from public celebrations. This situation, however, did not seem to slow down the activities of fashionable social butterflies like Peggy Shippen, who attended the social events in spite of snubs by patriots. Benedict hosted a ball, theoretically to improve public relations, inviting patriots as well as Tories and neutrals. This cannot have been a particularly happy mix, with the wealthy social set in high fashion, while others appeared in much more sober garb. It also gave Joseph Reed another opportunity to complain about Benedict Arnold’s behaviour. A subsequent ball on August 7 of 1778 in honour of a French minister exacerbated the situation, as the organizers felt the presence of the fashionable ladies of questionable loyalty was needed to suitably impress the French. Sometime during this social whirl, Arnold met Judge Shippen and ultimately his daughter Peggy. The exact where and when is not known, but he was her regular escort by late summer. Given the neutral (possibly Tory) sympathies of Judge Shippen and his family, this courtship was another point against Arnold in the eyes of Joseph Reed and others.
In September of 1778, Arnold asked Judge Shippen for Peggy’s hand by letter and wrote to Peggy, using the same letter he had sent to Betsey almost verbatim. There is no doubt that Arnold and Peggy were deeply in love. There were some issues that no doubt concerned Judge Shippen: Arnold’s lack of money and status, the fact he was a widower with three children, his age, and his physical limitation (his injured leg). While there was a possibility that Peggy’s marriage to Arnold could be an advantage, there were the rumours of Arnold’s speculations and other issues also to be considered. Arnold had had cargo that he owned at least in part moved from a ship, The Charming Nancy, to a warehouse using army wagons, which was illegal, although commonly done. He had also issued illegal passes allowing a loyalist to enter New York; when she was denied entry anyway, he tried to get her a legal pass unsuccessfully, which did not do him any good either. These activities had led to a formal complaint being lodged with the Supreme Executive Council.

By midwinter of 1778, Arnold’s reputation was at an all-time low, and his primary interest was marrying Peggy Shippen. He was also considering a return to civilian life. In love with Arnold, Peggy apparently finally accepted his proposal, contingent on her father’s approval, in January of 1779, which he finally gave. In February, Arnold left Philadelphia intending to go to General Washington for advice regarding his difficulties; after he left, the Supreme Executive Council accused him of military misconduct, filing eight separate charges, which were published. Although the Shippens and others were willing to believe that the accusations were examples of abuse of power by the Supreme Executive Council, it still left Arnold even deeper under a cloud than before. General Washington suggested that Arnold request a hearing with the Continental Congress; however, Arnold wanted a military court martial and a judgement of his peers. Data indicates that many in the army considered the charges against Arnold to be unfair. Ultimately, Arnold appealed to Congress. The matter was referred to a committee. Debate and protest by the Supreme Executive Council resulted in a decision that Arnold be judged on 4 of the accusations.

Mount Pleasant

On March 19, 1779, Arnold resigned as Major General of Philadelphia. He then bought Mount Pleasant, an elegant estate outside of Philadelphia, for over 16 thousand pounds, intending it to be an income-producing property to be held in trust for Peggy and their children. On April 3, 1779, General Washington announced that Benedict Arnold would face a court martial on the 4 charges. The wedding of Benedict Arnold and Peggy Shippen was celebrated on April 8, 1779, but the pending court martial clouded their honeymoon in spite of their being passionately in love. In fact, he contacted John Jay who was then president of the Second Continental Congress and a personal friend about the situation. Unfortunately, Mr. Jay was unable to assist. Arnold also appealed to General Washington for the earliest possible date for his court martial and asked that it be held in Philadelphia as access to records would be easier. Washington unfortunately was unable to accommodate the location request, and (although an early date had been set) had to delay the date at the request for more time by the Supreme Executive Committee. On May 5, 1779, Arnold responded to Washington in a furious letter protesting the delay. At this point, Arnold had been dissatisfied (to say the least) with his career in the Continental army, low in funds (and living beyond his means, since he and Peggy actually ended up living in Mount Pleasant and lived extremely well), and angry about the pending court martial. He had contacted Joseph Stansbury (an Englishman who was a Tory) on May 1, 1779 and told Mr. Stansbury he planned to defect to the British, in hopes of restoring British rule. He embroiled Mr. Stansbury in a plot, where Mr. Stansbury (in disguise) went to New York, met with Loyalist, Rev. Jonathon Odell, who knew Captain Andre’ (now one of General Sir Henry Clinton’s most trusted aides). Stansbury met with Captain Andre’ on May 10, 1779. Supposedly, along with Arnold’s defection plan, Stansbury also gave Captain Andre’ greetings from his old acquaintance Peggy Shippen. Captain Andre’ sent back detailed instructions for Arnold and (again supposedly) instructions for ciphered communication if Peggy decided to pursue further correspondence. Arnold was notified by Washington of the new court martial date of June 1, and accepted it. Andre’ also wrote to another old flame in Philadelphia, Peggy Chew, who was a friend of Peggy’s.

Arnold wrote to Captain Andre’ May 23, offering certain information and demanding money. This time, he offered salutations from his wife to Andre’. Subsequently, Arnold presented himself for his court martial at the appointed city, but got a note from Washington postponing it yet again; it was ultimately not held until December of 1779. Arnold continued his correspondence with Andre’, providing more information about troop movements and French reinforcements. It appears that during the summer of 1779, Andre’ was corresponding with Peggy Chew, and in August he wrote directly to Peggy Arnold, offering friendship and millinery supplies. It is important to note that there is no indication that Peggy Arnold had initiated any of the pleasantries extended to Andre’ in her name, nor that she had written to Andre’ herself at this time. It is also important to note that Peggy Shippen Arnold’s family destroyed all of her letters written prior to the Peace of Paris of September of 1783, which ended the American Revolution.

There was a great deal of unrest that summer, and Arnold had multiple unpleasant encounters. He asked Congress for protection for himself and his family (his sister and his sons now lived with him, and Peggy was pregnant). He was referred back to the Supreme Executive Committee, which was infuriating. After that episode, Peggy wrote to Andre’ (shortly to be Major John Andre’) October of 1799 in answer to his letter of August. It seems Peggy moved from providing sympathy for her husband’s trials, to providing active support for his endeavours at this point. Arnold’s court martial was rescheduled for a December date, and Arnold appeared for trial on December 23, 1779, pleading not guilty. Many expected him to be acquitted. Weather delayed things, as did the failure of the quartermaster to appear until January 19. On January 26, 1780, he was acquitted of all charges except that concerning an illegal pass, and he was sentenced to receive a reprimand from General Washington. This was a serious blow to Arnold, and it fell in a brutally hard winter, resulting in severe hardship for the soldiers especially. Arnold’s brightest spot was the birth of his and Peggy’s son Edward Shippen Arnold on March 19, 780.

This is not, however, the end of our story. Stay tuned for Part III on 18th November, 2016.

Sources:

Flexner, James Thomas. WASHINGTON The Indispensable Man. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1974. 
Stuart, Nancy Rubin. DEFIANT BRIDES The Untold Story of Two Revolutionary-Era Women and the Radical Men They Married. Boston: Beacon Presss, 2013.
Find A Grave.com. “Margaret ‘Peggy’ Shippen Arnold.” Posted by Peggy, Nov. 28, 2009. HERE ;
"Benedict Arnold." (No name or post date.) HERE
Scandalous Women blog. “Treacherous Beauty: The Life of Peggy Shippen Arnold.” Posted Nov. 1, 2012 by Elizabeth Kerry Mahon. HERE
Smithsonian.com. “Why Benedict Arnold Turned Traitor Against the American Revolution” by Nathan Philbrick. Smithsonian Magazine, May 2016. HERE
AmericanRevolution.org. “Margaret Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Penn University Archives and Records Center on line. “Edward Shippen (1729-1806).” HERE (no name or post date)
History.com. “Benedict Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Wikipedia. “The Philadelphia Campaign.” HERE

Images from Wikimedia Commons.
Benedict Arnold: By Thomas Hart (File:Benedict Arnold 1color.jpg) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Peggy Shippen and daughter: Daniel Gardner [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

~~~~~~~~~~

Lauren Gilbert lives in Florida with her husband. Her first book, HEYERWOOD A NOVEL, was published in 2011. Her second, A RATIONAL ATTACHMENT, is in process for release in 2017. Visit her website HERE



Thursday, November 3, 2016

Margaret Shippen Arnold, Collaborator or Dupe? - Part I

By Lauren Gilbert

Margaret Shippen was born on July 11, 1760 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Her father Edward Shippen IV and her mother Margaret Francis Shippen were both of prominent families, who were married in 1753. Edward Shippen completed his law studies in London and received a royal appointment as judge of the admiralty in 1755. He held other political offices, including a place on the Provincial Council, and was a man of great influence and authority in the city. The Shippens had several children (either 9 or 10 depending on the account) of whom Margaret, known as Peggy, was the youngest surviving child. She enjoyed the usual activities of girls and women of her time: drawing, needlework and music. By all accounts, she was pretty and intelligent, and became her father’s favourite. Indulged and spoiled, she was known for her high spirits, and for the fierce tantrums she threw if crossed. As she grew and spent time with her father, she also enjoyed reading newspapers and developed an interest in politics. The growing dissatisfaction in the colonies, and the fomenting of revolution, must have been a topic of great interest and concern for her father and Peggy.

Peggy Shippen and her daughter, c 1783-1789

Judge Shippen and his wife hosted many parties and dinners, entertaining individuals from both sides. By most accounts, the judge was sympathetic to the colonists’ grievances but was not convinced complete separation was the answer. He and his family walked the edge of the political knife during the era. However, Peggy and her sisters enjoyed the social round, and made the most of it. In addition to her looks and intelligence, Peggy had, by all accounts, a great deal of charm and wit, and was very popular. Judge Shippen lost his appointments in the spring of 1776, when the Continental Congress, located in Philadelphia, resolved that appointments stemming from the Crown be ended. (It is worth noting that a significant number of Pennsylvanians were moderate in view, and not certain that complete separation from Britain was the best solution; there were also Tories who sided with the Crown. It is also important to note that many families were divided by their loyalties, with some members loyal to the British and others espousing the American cause.) George Washington, Benedict Arnold and others were well known in Philadelphia; it is known that the Shippens entertained George Washington at dinner in 1774. The young ladies of Philadelphia could have socialized with individuals of all persuasions, not least Peggy Shippen. General William Howe and his British troops took and occupied Philadelphia in September 1777. For many Philadelphians, protecting one’s own interest became the primary consideration, which resulted in social interaction with the occupying British.

By all accounts, many of the young ladies of Philadelphia enjoyed the attentions of the British soldiers, in their dashing red uniforms and in possession of funds to hold more elaborate entertainments than the American troops had been able to provide. (Accounts also contain notes of unkind comments made about girls and women loyal to the American cause who wore linsey-woolsey gowns, either because they could not afford stylish garb or as a political statement of their loyalty.) One of the officers in the British contingent was a certain Captain John Andre. Young, good looking, well-educated and charming, he was a favourite with the ladies, and paid a great deal of attention to Peggy Shippen (and several other girls as well). Social events abounded. Dinners, plays, and a theatre built by the British allowed for a hectic social whirl. However, issues within the British command resulted in General William Howe’s departure from his command and return to England in May of 1778. To send the general off properly, Captain Andre and the British officers planned a grand entertainment and ball called the “Mischianza” to be held May 18.



The “Mischianza” was to be a gala event. The ladies invited to attend were to wear elaborate gowns and headdresses, which would have been quite expensive. Of course, Peggy and several other young Philadelphia belles were invited. Attendance at this event, held in a time of war, was a controversial affair. Held during a time of war, such an elaborate entertainment was a stark and tasteless contrast to the destruction so prevalent in the country. The Quaker community disapproved of the extravagant (and rather risqué) costumes that the girls were going to wear. Of course, the political ramifications of all of the socializing with the British in general were another consideration. Although some accounts indicate that Judge Shippen changed his mind and would not allow Peggy to go at the last minute, Captain Andre’s own account in a letter to a friend indicates she was there. (For Judge Shippen, Peggy’s attendance would be a shrewd move if the British did win the war, which at the time seemed a strong possibility; facing Peggy’s disappointment and dealing with the probable exhausting tantrum certainly was another consideration.) The ball was held in a decorated ballroom, followed by fireworks, a supper, and another ball. The celebrations lasted until dawn; obviously, the “Mischianza” was the ultimate event.

General Howe left May 24, 1778 and was replaced by Sir Henry Clinton. Subsequently, in June, the British army left Philadelphia. (Tides were turning; the French had allied with the Americans earlier in 1718. Many loyalists left with the British.) Clinton took his troops, captives and followers to New York, which was still held by the British. This, of course, resulted in many partings of friends and lovers, including the parting of Captain Andre from Peggy Shippen and his other Philadelphia flirtations. At some point, he gave Peggy a gold locket with a lock of his hair, and it is believed that he maintained contact with Peggy after the British departed. Subsequently, the Continental Army returned to Philadelphia. Knowing the divisions and difficulties to be faced in Philadelphia, Washington offered command as military governor to Benedict Arnold, charging him to restore the peace. Benedict Arnold was a hero of the Revolution, and seemed an excellent choice for the position.

Benedict Arnold at this time was a handsome and charismatic widower of 37 years of age with three children. He was still recovering from serious injury to his left leg. His mother had come from a wealthy family, but his father squandered their money. Benedict left school at 16 to apprentice as an apothecary. He worked in New Haven CT as an apothecary and bookseller. He had served in the British colonial militia. He subsequently joined the Continental army of the Americans in 1775 in Massachusetts. In 1776, he had been courting a young lady named Betsey DeBlois, writing a formal proposal letter to her. However, she did not accept. By 1778, Benedict Arnold had earned acclaim as a hero for his role in the American victory at Saratoga in October of 1777, as well as other earlier battles. Unfortunately, he also had difficulties in dealing with others, prone to criticize and ridicule anyone with whom he disagreed. He was impatient and unwilling to put up with anything that did not fit what he deemed necessary or correct. He made a lot of enemies for himself because of these attributes within the military, the Continental Congress and among civilians. On May 30, 1778, he swore an oath acknowledging the United States of America as a free country, owing no allegiance to Great Britain and renouncing his obedience to the king and to Great Britain while swearing to defend the United States and serve in the office of Major General to his best ability. The American military contingent entered the city June 18, 1778.


Benedict Arnold (detail from mezzotint March 26, 1776

Although (as you have seen) I am not addressing the American Revolution in all of its complexities in this post, there are some points that must be understood. The Continental Congress provided little money and provided it irregularly for the upkeep of the Continental army. Officers put in much (if not all) of their own funds to maintain their men and keep things going. Many faced bankruptcy. Promised payments were in arrears, and there was a great deal of hardship. Like General Washington, Arnold had put in much of what money he had and had been awaiting repayment. It was not uncommon for individuals to try to recoup some of their losses by selling commodities themselves. It is also important to note that Joseph Reed, who was an attorney and delegate to the Continental Congress, was a former aid of General Washington and admirer of General Horatio Gates (a rival of Washington), was vice president of the Supreme Executive Council which governed the state of Pennsylvania, and was not predisposed to like Benedict Arnold.


Part II continues the story, looking at Benedict Arnold's career (click here).


Sources include:

Flexner, James Thomas. WASHINGTON The Indispensable Man. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1974.
Stuart, Nancy Rubin. DEFIANT BRIDES The Untold Story of Two Revolutionary-Era Women and the Radical Men They Married. Boston: Beacon Presss, 2013.
Find A Grave.com. “Margaret ‘Peggy’ Shippen Arnold.” Posted by Peggy, Nov. 28, 2009. HERE ;
"Benedict Arnold." (No name or post date.) HERE
Scandalous Women blog. “Treacherous Beauty: The Life of Peggy Shippen Arnold.” Posted Nov. 1, 2012 by Elizabeth Kerry Mahon. HERE
Smithsonian.com. “Why Benedict Arnold Turned Traitor Against the American Revolution” by Nathan Philbrick. Smithsonian Magazine, May 2016. HERE
AmericanRevolution.org. “Margaret Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Penn University Archives and Records Center on line. “Edward Shippen (1729-1806).” HERE (no name or post date)
History.com. “Benedict Arnold.” HERE (No name or post date)
Wikipedia. “The Philadelphia Campaign.” HERE

Images from Wikimedia Commons.

~~~~~~~~~~

Lauren Gilbert lives in Florida with her husband. Her first book, HEYERWOOD A NOVEL, was published in 2011. Her second, A RATIONAL ATTACHMENT, is in process for release in 2017. Visit her website HERE